![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Reviewer to Battloid mode
Dec. 11th, 2008 10:47 amFour years after the OAV series concluded in Japan, I have finally found time to sit and watch through Macross Zero. For my part, I was disappointed in the show.
The CGI effects of the Valkyrie fighters made up a high point - the opening chapter demonstrates a drawn-out Fighter-to-Battloid transformation sequence that nearly made me drool. Sadly, the actual plot and characters brought me right back down. The series suffered from prequel-itis: I knew the Earth wouldn't be destroyed, because that job would fall to the Zentraedi in four years. For the same reason, I knew that Roy Focker wouldn't be killed in combat, making his dogfight duels mildly tedious.
A repeated subplot is the preservation of the ancient ways of the island people, which again felt moot with the coming holocaust; and the bad guys only received the personalities of one-dimensional psychopaths. I expect better than that in anime. One of them had the nerve to try a sympathy ploy on the audience minutes after napalming a village of non-combatant islanders. I just wanted them to hurry up and get killed in combat so we could get back to the real plot.
Oh, and late in the series, there's the standard anime "I have taken it upon myself to decide that humanity has reached a dead end so I shall cause their destruction in order to pave the way for the next rulers of the Earth" scientist. Isn't that one on TV Tropes yet? Boring. Lame. Move on.
Still, I feel more "caught up" on the Macross mythology now, so I'm ready to hit Macross Frontier next. As always, your mileage may vary.
The CGI effects of the Valkyrie fighters made up a high point - the opening chapter demonstrates a drawn-out Fighter-to-Battloid transformation sequence that nearly made me drool. Sadly, the actual plot and characters brought me right back down. The series suffered from prequel-itis: I knew the Earth wouldn't be destroyed, because that job would fall to the Zentraedi in four years. For the same reason, I knew that Roy Focker wouldn't be killed in combat, making his dogfight duels mildly tedious.
A repeated subplot is the preservation of the ancient ways of the island people, which again felt moot with the coming holocaust; and the bad guys only received the personalities of one-dimensional psychopaths. I expect better than that in anime. One of them had the nerve to try a sympathy ploy on the audience minutes after napalming a village of non-combatant islanders. I just wanted them to hurry up and get killed in combat so we could get back to the real plot.
Oh, and late in the series, there's the standard anime "I have taken it upon myself to decide that humanity has reached a dead end so I shall cause their destruction in order to pave the way for the next rulers of the Earth" scientist. Isn't that one on TV Tropes yet? Boring. Lame. Move on.
Still, I feel more "caught up" on the Macross mythology now, so I'm ready to hit Macross Frontier next. As always, your mileage may vary.
