Review: Starship Exeter
Aug. 31st, 2004 09:49 amIf you don't have any interest in the original TV Star Trek, or low-budget film-making, you can skip this. A couple months ago, I was reading a back issue of Star Trek Communicator and I found a link to a Trek fan film called Starship Exeter.
rattrap posted a similar link not long afterward, and this weekend I got around to downloading and watching this 2002 production.
Let's start with what they did wrong. The script has a few "well why didn't the characters do X?" moments. The aliens are a bit oddly acted in places, and the production crew admits to regretting a certain monster model.
That's all. Everything else is freaking perfect. The costumes are right. The sets are right. The props are right, the sound effects are right, the characters are right out of 2270's Starfleet. They even made their gorgeous CGI Constitution-class starship wobble at the same place the Enterprise used to wobble in certain shots. I was completely transported (no pun intended) back to a time when a determined humanity was making its mark in the Trek universe, whether alien races liked it or not.
This brings me to another point. Say all you want about certain cheesy aspects of classic Trek, it was one of the most high-budget TV shows of the 60's - nobody did anything with better production values back then. Starship Exeter is so well-done that if it was showing on cable right now, it could fool you for a moment into thinking that you were watching another Roddenberry spin-off pilot. Low-budget film-making is catching up to Hollywood faster and faster - one reviewer stated that he'd rather watch Exeter than Nemesis.
This was a joy to watch, not just for the nostalgia overload, but as the herald of what's to come for those of us with DV cameras and a few thousand bucks. I highly recommend it.
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
Let's start with what they did wrong. The script has a few "well why didn't the characters do X?" moments. The aliens are a bit oddly acted in places, and the production crew admits to regretting a certain monster model.
That's all. Everything else is freaking perfect. The costumes are right. The sets are right. The props are right, the sound effects are right, the characters are right out of 2270's Starfleet. They even made their gorgeous CGI Constitution-class starship wobble at the same place the Enterprise used to wobble in certain shots. I was completely transported (no pun intended) back to a time when a determined humanity was making its mark in the Trek universe, whether alien races liked it or not.
This brings me to another point. Say all you want about certain cheesy aspects of classic Trek, it was one of the most high-budget TV shows of the 60's - nobody did anything with better production values back then. Starship Exeter is so well-done that if it was showing on cable right now, it could fool you for a moment into thinking that you were watching another Roddenberry spin-off pilot. Low-budget film-making is catching up to Hollywood faster and faster - one reviewer stated that he'd rather watch Exeter than Nemesis.
This was a joy to watch, not just for the nostalgia overload, but as the herald of what's to come for those of us with DV cameras and a few thousand bucks. I highly recommend it.